Science Protects us from Child-Rearing Pseudoscience

We want certainty, and that leaves us open to fraud. Mothers used to lie awake listening to their babies scream because the experts said not to pick the baby up or to feed "off schedule." They might well have felt that bloodletting would have been preferable.

One benefit of knowing the science is a kind of protective skepticism. It should make us deeply suspicious of any enterprise that offers a formula for making babies smarter or teaching them more, from flash cards to Mozart tapes to Better Baby Institutes. Everything we know about babies suggests that these artificial interventions are at best useless and at worst distractions from the normal interaction between grown-ups and babies. Babies are already as smart as they can be, they know what they need to know, and they are very effective and selective in getting the kinds of information they need. They are designed to learn about the real world that surrounds them, and they learn by playing with the things in that world, most of all by playing with the people who love them. Not the least advantage of knowing about science is that it immunizes us from pseudoscience.


Like Baby Einstein videos and doctors who say the baby should be allowed to cry alone all night.

Folksonomies: science pseudoscience parenting evidence-based medicine child-rearing

/science (0.551391)
/family and parenting/babies and toddlers (0.540162)
/society/crime/property crime/fraud (0.303545)

Baby Einstein videos (0.991398 (negative:-0.464784)), Better Baby Institutes (0.858687 (positive:0.351435)), babies (0.797010 (negative:-0.412929)), Child-Rearing Pseudoscience (0.755562 (negative:-0.464784)), awake listening (0.604761 (negative:-0.541251)), worst distractions (0.582137 (negative:-0.878093)), protective skepticism (0.574172 (positive:0.829992)), Mozart tapes (0.549332 (positive:0.351435)), artificial interventions (0.544517 (negative:-0.878093)), normal interaction (0.531645 (negative:-0.878093)), flash cards (0.531084 (positive:0.351435)), real world (0.482290 (positive:0.570693)), certainty (0.236178 (neutral:0.000000)), grown-ups (0.222842 (negative:-0.878093))

Better Baby Institutes:Organization (0.893516 (positive:0.351435)), fraud:Crime (0.528368 (negative:-0.496937))

English-language films (0.929981): dbpedia
Need to know (0.887266): dbpedia | freebase | yago
Scientific method (0.783674): dbpedia | freebase
Science (0.760183): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Baby Einstein (0.714328): website | dbpedia | freebase | yago
Learning (0.653021): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Psychology (0.614313): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Infant (0.614100): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc

 The Scientist in the Crib: What Early Learning Tells Us About the Mind
Books, Brochures, and Chapters>Book:  Gopnik , Meltzoff , Kuhl (2001-01-01), The Scientist in the Crib: What Early Learning Tells Us About the Mind, Harper Paperbacks, Retrieved on 2011-07-06
Folksonomies: education parenting pregnancy babies children infancy