Consumers of Alternative News are More Likely to Fall for Troll Memes

Most of the online activism Facebook pages contain claims that mainstream media is manipulated by higher entities (and thus the information is be not neutral or reliable). Such an antagonism makes any kind of persuasion process, even if based on more solid information, very dicult. As a response to partisan debates, the emergent groups of trolls began to provide parodistic imitations of a wide range of online partisan topics. Despite the evident parodistic (and sometimes paradoxical) contents, not rarely, troll memes fomented animated debates and diused through the community as any other information would. Through statistical analysis, we nd that the consumption patterns are similar despite the dierent nature of the information. Finally, in order to uncover more characteristics of the process, we distinguished users with strong aliations and observed their respective interaction patterns, as well as with false information inoculated in that portion of the Facebook ecosystem. We nd that, out of the 1279 labeled users interacting with the troll memes, a dominant percentage (56% , as opposed to 26% and 18% for other groups) is constituted of users preeminently interacting with alternative information sources and thus more exposed to unsubstantiated claims. The results of our study raise a real warning, as the higher the number of circulating unsubstantiated claims is, the more users will be biased in selecting contents.

Notes:

Memes that are satirical or paradoxical.

Folksonomies: media truth paranoia conspiracy theories

Taxonomies:
/law, govt and politics/politics (0.576883)
/religion and spirituality (0.291366)
/science/mathematics/statistics (0.259350)

Keywords:
Troll Memes Memes (0.965617 (negative:-0.644238)), activism Facebook pages (0.732390 (neutral:0.000000)), online partisan topics (0.716400 (negative:-0.748023)), unsubstantiated claims (0.678035 (negative:-0.468541)), respective interaction patterns (0.671365 (positive:0.242230)), alternative information sources (0.654209 (negative:-0.591829)), partisan debates (0.605613 (negative:-0.707823)), ) contents, not rarely, troll memes fomented animated debates and diused through the community as any other information would. (0.582984 (neutral:0.000000)), Alternative News (0.573027 (negative:-0.644238)), Facebook ecosystem (0.572119 (neutral:0.000000)), higher entities (0.571487 (neutral:0.000000)), parodistic imitations (0.569705 (negative:-0.748023)), mainstream media (0.568659 (neutral:0.000000)), persuasion process (0.565172 (negative:-0.507568)), emergent groups (0.562791 (negative:-0.748023)), solid information (0.560555 (neutral:0.000000)), wide range (0.558915 (negative:-0.748023)), dominant percentage (0.557253 (negative:-0.388278)), statistical analysis (0.552815 (neutral:0.000000)), dierent nature (0.551978 (neutral:0.000000)), consumption patterns (0.549667 (neutral:0.000000)), real warning (0.548732 (negative:-0.553962)), false information (0.548078 (neutral:0.000000)), strong aliations (0.547077 (positive:0.242230)), users (0.482246 (negative:-0.246010)), antagonism (0.447542 (negative:-0.507568)), trolls (0.437302 (negative:-0.748023)), Consumers (0.428543 (negative:-0.644238)), portion (0.428311 (neutral:0.000000)), kind (0.428307 (negative:-0.507568))

Entities:
Facebook:Company (0.931873 (neutral:0.000000)), mainstream media:FieldTerminology (0.538283 (neutral:0.000000)), 18%:Quantity (0.538283 (neutral:0.000000)), 26%:Quantity (0.538283 (neutral:0.000000)), 56%:Quantity (0.538283 (neutral:0.000000))

Concepts:
Emergence (0.878950): dbpedia | freebase
Facebook (0.747600): website | dbpedia | freebase | yago | crunchbase
The Higher (0.746293): dbpedia | freebase | yago
Troll (0.745835): dbpedia | freebase
Interaction (0.744874): dbpedia | freebase
Alternative media (0.744670): dbpedia | freebase | yago
Critical thinking (0.723913): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc | yago
Mainstream (0.723677): dbpedia | freebase

 Collective attention in the age of (mis)information
Periodicals>Journal Article:  Mocanu, Rossi, Zhang, Karsai, Quattrociocchi (13 Mar 2014), Collective attention in the age of (mis)information, Retrieved on 2014-04-21
  • Source Material [arxiv.org]
  • Folksonomies: world wide web information psychology


    Triples

    21 APR 2014

     Suspicion of Authority

    "Susicion of Authority" is Also Propaganda > Cause and Effect > Consumers of Alternative News are More Likely to Fall for Troll Memes
     
    Folksonomies: conspiracy
    Folksonomies: conspiracy