Neurons are Domesticated Cells

You really don't have to worry about one part of your laptop going rogue and trying out something on its own that the rest of the system doesn't want to do. No, they're all slaves. If they're agents, they're slaves. They are prisoners. They have very clear job descriptions. They get fed every day. They don't have to worry about where the energy's coming from, and they're not ambitious. They just do what they're asked to do and do it brilliantly with only the slightest tint of comprehension. You get all the power of computers out of these mindless little robotic slave prisoners, but that's not the way your brain is organized.

Each neuron is imprisoned in your brain. I now think of these as cells within cells, as cells within prison cells. Realize that every neuron in your brain, every human cell in your body (leaving aside all the symbionts), is a direct descendent of eukaryotic cells that lived and fended for themselves for about a billion years as free-swimming, free-living little agents. They fended for themselves, and they survived.

They had to develop an awful lot of know-how, a lot of talent, a lot of self-protective talent to do that. When they joined forces into multi-cellular creatures, they gave up a lot of that. They became, in effect, domesticated. They became part of larger, more monolithic organizations. My hunch is that that's true in general. We don't have to worry about our muscle cells rebelling against us, or anything like that. When they do, we call it cancer, but in the brain I think that (and this is my wild idea) maybe only in one species, us, and maybe only in the obviously more volatile parts of the brain, the cortical areas, some little switch has been thrown in the genetics that, in effect, makes our neurons a little bit feral, a little bit like what happens when you let sheep or pigs go feral, and they recover their wild talents very fast.

Maybe a lot of the neurons in our brains are not just capable but, if you like, motivated to be more adventurous, more exploratory or risky in the way they comport themselves, in the way they live their lives. They're struggling amongst themselves with each other for influence, just for staying alive, and there's competition going on between individual neurons. As soon as that happens, you have room for cooperation to create alliances, and I suspect that a more free-wheeling, anarchic organization is the secret of our greater capacities of creativity, imagination, thinking outside the box and all that, and the price we pay for it is our susceptibility to obsessions, mental illnesses, delusions and smaller problems.


But they are also slightly feral. Neurons compete with one another, the brain works by neural pruning, natural selection. Cells that don't get used are allowed to die. Thus, neurons are motivated to survive, to have some independence.

Folksonomies: biology natural selection brain cognition cells

/science/biology/cytology (0.568147)
/business and industrial/agriculture and forestry/livestock (0.466514)
/society/unrest and war (0.447145)

cells (0.980793 (negative:-0.454613)), neurons (0.914162 (negative:-0.042198)), clear job descriptions (0.903706 (positive:0.633708)), robotic slave prisoners (0.903619 (negative:-0.628917)), free-living little agents (0.877127 (negative:-0.465045)), little bit (0.802944 (negative:-0.606144)), individual neurons (0.800277 (neutral:0.000000)), eukaryotic cells (0.783863 (neutral:0.000000)), prison cells (0.775212 (negative:-0.446075)), muscle cells (0.767499 (negative:-0.618604)), brain (0.725441 (negative:-0.448375)), slightest tint (0.723122 (neutral:0.000000)), neural pruning (0.713456 (neutral:0.000000)), natural selection (0.707317 (positive:0.491975)), multi-cellular creatures (0.685892 (neutral:0.000000)), monolithic organizations (0.678130 (neutral:0.000000)), direct descendent (0.675474 (neutral:0.000000)), anarchic organization (0.668924 (positive:0.403546)), human cell (0.666642 (neutral:0.000000)), cortical areas (0.661546 (negative:-0.384265)), self-protective talent (0.658360 (positive:0.455554)), volatile parts (0.656984 (negative:-0.408641)), greater capacities (0.656723 (positive:0.403546)), mental illnesses (0.648377 (negative:-0.574930)), smaller problems (0.648075 (neutral:0.000000)), little switch (0.640860 (negative:-0.485017)), wild talents (0.639669 (neutral:0.000000)), wild idea (0.637604 (neutral:0.000000)), slaves (0.541797 (negative:-0.322330)), way (0.539673 (negative:-0.529185))

billion years:Quantity (0.010000 (neutral:0.000000))

Cerebral cortex (0.983234): dbpedia | freebase
Brain (0.964214): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Neuron (0.866412): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Human brain (0.858468): dbpedia | freebase
Nervous system (0.847951): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Prison (0.802176): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Psychology (0.747817): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Cerebellum (0.708991): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc

 The Normal Well-Tempered Mind
Electronic/World Wide Web>Internet Article:  Dennet, Daniel (1/8/2013), The Normal Well-Tempered Mind, Edge, Retrieved on 2013-09-17
  • Source Material []
  • Folksonomies: computer science emergence mind


    17 SEP 2013

     Brains Grow by Natural Selection

    How Brains Grow Into Bodies > Cause and Effect > Neurons are Domesticated Cells
    Because brains grow into bodies by neural-pruning, the neurons in our brains are subject to natural selection and are different from our other cells by their need to survive giving them some independence.