Science Because it is Fulfilling

To prove to an indignant questioner on the spur of the moment that the work I do was useful seemed a thankless task and I gave it up. I turned to him with a smile and finished, 'To tell you the truth we don't do it because it is useful but because it's amusing.' The answer was thought of and given in a moment: it came from deep down in my soul, and the results were as admirable from my point of view as unexpected. My audience was clearly on my side. Prolonged and hearty applause greeted my confession. My questioner retired shaking his head over my wickedness and the newspapers next day, with obvious approval, came out with headlines 'Scientist Does It Because It's Amusing!' And if that is not the best reason why a scientist should do his work, I want to know what is. Would it be any good to ask a mother what practical use her baby is? That, as I say, was the first evening I ever spent in the United States and from that moment I felt at home. I realised that all talk about science purely for its practical and wealth-producing results is as idle in this country as in England. Practical results will follow right enough. No real knowledge is sterile. The most useless investigation may prove to have the most startling practical importance: Wireless telegraphy might not yet have come if Clerk Maxwell had been drawn away from his obviously 'useless' equations to do something of more practical importance. Large branches of chemistry would have remained obscure had Willard Gibbs not spent his time at mathematical calculations which only about two men of his generation could understand. With this faith in the ultimate usefulness of all real knowledge a man may proceed to devote himself to a study of first causes without apology, and without hope of immediate return.


Quoting A.V. Hill's anecdote.

Folksonomies: science purpose

/science (0.515751)
/art and entertainment/movies and tv/movies (0.473511)
/family and parenting/children (0.413559)

startling practical importance (0.947169 (neutral:0.000000)), real knowledge (0.925392 (negative:-0.226319)), hearty applause (0.788281 (positive:0.867835)), indignant questioner (0.786376 (negative:-0.756705)), A.V. Hill (0.760651 (positive:0.416798)), thankless task (0.753483 (negative:-0.756705)), obvious approval (0.742387 (positive:0.285216)), Willard Gibbs (0.724361 (neutral:0.000000)), useless investigation (0.720276 (neutral:0.000000)), best reason (0.719879 (negative:-0.557943)), ultimate usefulness (0.713719 (positive:0.545944)), Clerk Maxwell (0.712163 (negative:-0.397128)), Wireless telegraphy (0.710806 (negative:-0.387686)), United States (0.704475 (neutral:0.000000)), mathematical calculations (0.701175 (neutral:0.000000)), Large branches (0.697791 (neutral:0.000000)), immediate return (0.695620 (neutral:0.000000)), Practical results (0.691083 (positive:0.907310)), wealth-producing results (0.687662 (neutral:0.000000)), moment (0.672379 (negative:-0.511359)), work (0.520611 (negative:-0.657324)), science (0.518828 (positive:0.416798)), wickedness (0.498302 (negative:-0.343604)), anecdote (0.490841 (positive:0.416798)), spur (0.476466 (negative:-0.756705)), smile (0.472475 (positive:0.679739)), apology (0.467010 (positive:0.545944)), scientist (0.466232 (negative:-0.557943)), confession (0.464011 (positive:0.867835)), audience (0.460824 (neutral:0.000000))

scientist:JobTitle (0.881898 (negative:-0.058453)), A.V. Hill:Person (0.804042 (positive:0.548269)), Clerk Maxwell:Person (0.767672 (negative:-0.397128)), Willard Gibbs:Person (0.682003 (neutral:0.000000)), Wireless telegraphy:FieldTerminology (0.627228 (negative:-0.387686)), United States:Country (0.542524 (neutral:0.000000)), England:Country (0.491282 (neutral:0.000000))

United States (0.960932): website | dbpedia | ciaFactbook | freebase | opencyc | yago
Truth (0.731832): dbpedia | freebase
Maxwell's equations (0.676824): dbpedia | freebase | yago
Thermodynamics (0.661966): dbpedia | freebase
Science (0.593328): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Mathematics (0.581436): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Gibbs free energy (0.541556): dbpedia | freebase | yago
Radio (0.538067): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc

 The History of Neuroscience in Autobiography
Books, Brochures, and Chapters>Book:  Squire , Larry R. (2011-09-09), The History of Neuroscience in Autobiography, Oxford University Press, USA, Retrieved on 2012-06-04
  • Source Material []