Why Science and Religion are Irreconcilable

To begin with, the findings of science entail that the belief systems of all the world’s traditional religions and cultures—their theories of the origins of life, humans, and societies—are factually mistaken. We know, but our ancestors did not, that humans belong to a single species of African primate that developed agriculture, government, and writing late in its history. We know that our species is a tiny twig of a genealogical tree that embraces all living things and that emerged from prebiotic chemicals almost four billion years ago. We know that we live on a planet that revolves around one of a hundred billion stars in our galaxy, which is one of a hundred billion galaxies in a 13.8-billion-year-old universe, possibly one of a vast number of universes. We know that our intuitions about space, time, matter, and causation are incommensurable with the nature of reality on scales that are very large and very small. We know that the laws governing the physical world (including accidents, disease, and other misfortunes) have no goals that pertain to human well-being. There is no such thing as fate, providence, karma, spells, curses, augury, divine retribution, or answered prayers—though the discrepancy between the laws of probability and the workings of cognition may explain why people believe there are. And we know that we did not always know these things, that the beloved convictions of every time and culture may be decisively falsified, doubtless including some we hold today.

In other words, the worldview that guides the moral and spiritual values of an educated person today is the worldview given to us by science. Though the scientific facts do not by themselves dictate values, they certainly hem in the possibilities. By stripping ecclesiastical authority of its credibility on factual matters, they cast doubt on its claims to certitude in matters of morality. The scientific refutation of the theory of vengeful gods and occult forces undermines practices such as human sacrifice, witch hunts, faith healing, trial by ordeal, and the persecution of heretics. The facts of science, by exposing the absence of purpose in the laws governing the universe, force us to take responsibility for the welfare of ourselves, our species, and our planet. For the same reason, they undercut any moral or political system based on mystical forces, quests, destinies, dialectics, struggles, or messianic ages. And in combination with a few unexceptionable convictions— that all of us value our own welfare and that we are social beings who impinge on each other and can negotiate codes of conduct—the scientific facts militate toward a defensible morality, namely adhering to principles that maximize the flourishing of humans and other sentient beings. This humanism, which is inextricable from a scientific understanding of the world, is becoming the de facto morality of modern democracies, international organizations, and liberalizing religions, and its unfulfilled promises define the moral imperatives we face today.

Notes:

Steven Pinker's critique of why "non-overlapping magesteria" doesn't work.

Folksonomies: science religion non-overlapping magesteria

Taxonomies:
/science (0.462329)
/law, govt and politics (0.284514)
/religion and spirituality (0.249186)

Keywords:
Irreconcilable Steven Pinker (0.966545 (negative:-0.550252)), forces undermines practices (0.910929 (negative:-0.612728)), scientific facts (0.875955 (positive:0.444271)), science entail (0.820916 (neutral:0.000000)), non-overlapping magesteria (0.820297 (negative:-0.226241)), prebiotic chemicals (0.801707 (positive:0.440215)), defensible morality (0.799875 (positive:0.444271)), traditional religions (0.798354 (neutral:0.000000)), facto morality (0.793834 (positive:0.265090)), belief systems (0.790855 (neutral:0.000000)), cultures—their theories (0.788940 (neutral:0.000000)), moral imperatives (0.788815 (negative:-0.342879)), single species (0.784835 (neutral:0.000000)), African primate (0.784464 (neutral:0.000000)), genealogical tree (0.780098 (positive:0.440215)), tiny twig (0.779400 (positive:0.440215)), sentient beings (0.778216 (positive:0.706584)), divine retribution (0.777893 (positive:0.325372)), vengeful gods (0.777308 (negative:-0.612728)), vast number (0.777307 (positive:0.459336)), 13.8-billion-year-old universe (0.777010 (neutral:0.000000)), beloved convictions (0.776845 (neutral:0.000000)), physical world (0.775852 (neutral:0.000000)), unfulfilled promises (0.775515 (negative:-0.342879)), scientific refutation (0.774006 (negative:-0.612728)), social beings (0.773360 (positive:0.444271)), human well-being (0.771322 (neutral:0.000000)), modern democracies (0.769759 (positive:0.265090)), scientific understanding (0.766006 (neutral:0.000000)), factual matters (0.765672 (negative:-0.486830))

Entities:
Steven Pinker:Person (0.836760 (negative:-0.550252)), four billion years:Quantity (0.836760 (neutral:0.000000)), billion-year:Quantity (0.836760 (neutral:0.000000))

Concepts:
Universe (0.962139): dbpedia | freebase
Religion (0.940943): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Human (0.705672): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Morality (0.650714): dbpedia | freebase
Science (0.629148): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Reality (0.613607): dbpedia | freebase
Scientific method (0.595549): dbpedia | freebase
Nature (0.580740): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc

 Science Is Not Your Enemy An impassioned plea to neglected novelists, embattled professors, and tenure-less historians
Electronic/World Wide Web>Internet Article:  Pinker, Steven (August 6, 2013), Science Is Not Your Enemy An impassioned plea to neglected novelists, embattled professors, and tenure-less historians, New Republic, Retrieved on 2013-12-10
  • Source Material [www.newrepublic.com]
  • Folksonomies: science culture two cultures humanities


    Triples

    10 DEC 2013

     Science and Religion

    Why Science and Religion are Irreconcilable > Contrast > Appreciate the Beauty of Wrong Ideas
    Irreconcilable, but that does not make one wrong?
    Folksonomies: science religion
    Folksonomies: science religion