Herschel's Heterodox Opinions
Laplace’s cool confidence in avowing atheistical sentiments was legendary. The story was told that after Napoleon had inspected a copy of Laplace’s Systéme du Monde, he challenged the astronomer about his beliefs. ‘Monsieur Laplace! Newton has frequently spoken of God in his book. I have already gone over yours, and I have not found His name mentioned a single time.’ To this Laplace made the magnificent and disdainful reply: ‘Citizen First Consul, I have no need of that hypothesis.’
Herschel however was still interested in extraterrestrial life, and in 1795 published one of his most extraordinary papers, ‘On the Nature and Construction of the Sun’, with the Royal Society, suggesting that the sun had a cool, solid interior and was inhabited by intelligent beings. He reiterated his original claim that the moon was inhabited, and added that by analogy ‘numberless globes’ among the stars must support ‘living creatures’. However, he disapproved of God-hunting within the galaxy, and attacked the ‘fanciful poets’ who had suggested that the sun was ‘a fit place for the punishment of the wicked’, viz. a fiery hell constructed for divine vengeance.
Unlike Joseph Priestley, whose library was burnt down by a Birmingham mob in 1794, Herschel managed to avoid any public reputation for heterodox opinions.
Notes:
He believed in aliens living in the Sun, rejected praise for god in his work, but managed to avoid having his library burned down.
Folksonomies: history science atheism
Taxonomies:
/science/mathematics (0.696116)
/science/physics (0.340182)
/law, govt and politics (0.278288)
Keywords:
heterodox opinions (0.903101 (negative:-0.525916)), Systéme du Monde (0.790757 (neutral:0.000000)), analogy ‘numberless globes (0.744924 (neutral:0.000000)), ‘Monsieur Laplace (0.718725 (neutral:0.000000)), atheistical sentiments (0.537365 (positive:0.621365)), cool confidence (0.533403 (positive:0.621365)), ‘Citizen First Consul (0.523112 (neutral:0.000000)), Herschel (0.515616 (negative:-0.525916)), disdainful reply (0.509774 (positive:0.525937)), Joseph Priestley (0.504600 (neutral:0.000000)), extraterrestrial life (0.503671 (neutral:0.000000)), extraordinary papers (0.496594 (positive:0.379727)), single time. (0.494968 (neutral:0.000000)), intelligent beings (0.490335 (positive:0.749129)), Birmingham mob (0.488566 (negative:-0.431763)), fiery hell (0.488539 (neutral:0.000000)), public reputation (0.485592 (negative:-0.646095)), divine vengeance (0.485277 (neutral:0.000000)), Royal Society (0.484759 (neutral:0.000000)), original claim (0.482189 (neutral:0.000000)), fit place (0.472656 (negative:-0.410940)), ‘fanciful poets (0.468239 (negative:-0.454332)), sun (0.391286 (negative:-0.003097)), god (0.309438 (negative:-0.175778)), library (0.303748 (negative:-0.610531)), aliens (0.266236 (negative:-0.405738)), Napoleon (0.264709 (neutral:0.000000)), astronomer (0.264576 (neutral:0.000000)), praise (0.259621 (negative:-0.657447)), hypothesis (0.259365 (neutral:0.000000))
Entities:
Laplace:City (0.912910 (positive:0.573651)), Herschel:Person (0.618671 (negative:-0.458099)), Joseph Priestley:Person (0.278381 (neutral:0.000000)), Napoleon:Person (0.269752 (neutral:0.000000)), avowing atheistical:City (0.261505 (positive:0.621365)), Royal Society:Organization (0.237617 (neutral:0.000000)), Newton:Person (0.229088 (positive:0.481669)), Birmingham:City (0.223504 (negative:-0.431763))
Concepts:
Sun (0.988505): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Moon (0.814125): dbpedia | freebase
Oxygen (0.712545): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Planet (0.698908): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
NASA (0.682779): geo | website | dbpedia | freebase | opencyc | yago | crunchbase
Milky Way (0.674057): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc | yago
Star (0.657993): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Mars (0.628603): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc | yago
The Age of Wonder