There is No Definition of "Species"
There is no authoritative definition of “species.” The most widely accepted definition describes a group of organisms that can procreate with one another and produce fertile offspring, but there are many exceptions. De-extinction operates under a different definition altogether. Revive & Restore hopes to create a bird that interacts with its ecosystem as the passenger pigeon did. If the new bird fills the same ecological niche, it will be successful; if not, back to the petri dish. “It’s ecological resurrection, not species resurrection,” Shapiro says. A similar logic informs the restoration of Renaissance paintings. If you visit “The Last Supper” in the refectory of the Convent of Santa Maria delle Grazie in Milan, you won’t see a single speck of paint from the brush of Leonardo da Vinci. You will see a mural with the same proportions and design as the original, and you may feel the same sense of awe as the refectory’s parishioners felt in 1498, but the original artwork disappeared centuries ago. Philosophers call this Theseus’ Paradox, a reference to the ship that Theseus sailed back to Athens from Crete after he had slain the Minotaur. The ship, Plutarch writes, was preserved by the Athenians, who “took away the old planks as they decayed, putting in new and stronger timber in their place.” Theseus’ ship, therefore, “became a standing example among the philosophers . . . one side holding that the ship remained the same, and the other contending that it was not the same.”
What does it matter whether Passenger Pigeon 2.0 is a real passenger pigeon or a persuasive impostor? If the new, synthetically created bird enriches the ecology of the forests it populates, few people, including conservationists, will object. The genetically adjusted birds would hardly be the first aspect of the deciduous forest ecosystem to bear man’s influence; invasive species, disease, deforestation and a toxic atmosphere have engineered forests that would be unrecognizable to the continent’s earliest European settlers. When human beings first arrived, the continent was populated by camels, eight-foot beavers and 550-pound ground sloths. “People grow up with this idea that the nature they see is ‘natural,’ ” Novak says, “but there’s been no real ‘natural’ element to the earth the entire time humans have been around.”
Notes:
Which raises the question of resurrecting species, is the resurrected the same species?
Folksonomies: biology definition species
Taxonomies:
/pets/birds (0.498965)
/science/biology/zoology/endangered species (0.446132)
/art and entertainment/visual art and design/painting (0.381749)
Keywords:
passenger pigeon (0.974499 (positive:0.544462)), widely accepted definition (0.852707 (positive:0.300748)), ‘natural’ element to the earth the entire time humans have been around.'' (0.795379 (negative:-0.318174)), real passenger pigeon (0.792145 (positive:0.571637)), Leonardo da Vinci (0.777211 (neutral:0.000000)), 550-pound ground sloths (0.765873 (negative:-0.238617)), deciduous forest ecosystem (0.760692 (neutral:0.000000)), genetically adjusted birds (0.757374 (neutral:0.000000)), earliest European settlers (0.742733 (negative:-0.467565)), entire time humans (0.736742 (neutral:0.000000)), ’ Paradox, a reference to the ship that Theseus sailed back to Athens from Crete after he had slain the Minotaur. (0.676725 (neutral:0.000000)), ’ ship, therefore, ``became a standing example among the philosophers . . . one side holding that the ship (0.671978 (neutral:0.000000)), authoritative definition (0.668306 (negative:-0.268760)), different definition (0.656678 (neutral:0.000000)), fertile offspring (0.641498 (positive:0.300748)), petri dish (0.626660 (neutral:0.000000)), species resurrection (0.625197 (neutral:0.000000)), persuasive impostor (0.621126 (positive:0.571637)), single speck (0.616130 (neutral:0.000000)), ecological resurrection (0.615206 (neutral:0.000000)), ecological niche (0.612143 (neutral:0.000000)), new bird (0.610191 (neutral:0.000000)), similar logic (0.607895 (positive:0.343917)), old planks (0.607783 (neutral:0.000000)), Santa Maria (0.600752 (neutral:0.000000)), Renaissance paintings (0.600735 (positive:0.343917)), original artwork (0.597632 (neutral:0.000000)), stronger timber (0.596772 (positive:0.221590)), human beings (0.595358 (neutral:0.000000)), invasive species (0.591055 (negative:-0.602742))
Entities:
Leonardo da Vinci:Facility (0.741051 (neutral:0.000000)), Convent of Santa Maria:Facility (0.734949 (neutral:0.000000)), Shapiro:Person (0.678606 (neutral:0.000000)), Novak:Person (0.674803 (neutral:0.000000)), Milan:City (0.663787 (neutral:0.000000)), Athens:City (0.653294 (negative:-0.344200)), Crete:City (0.594064 (negative:-0.344200)), eight-foot:Quantity (0.594064 (neutral:0.000000)), 550-pound:Quantity (0.594064 (neutral:0.000000))
Concepts:
Leonardo da Vinci (0.974242): dbpedia | freebase | yago
Ecology (0.651836): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Invasive species (0.599864): dbpedia | freebase | yago
Human (0.495975): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Ecosystem (0.495593): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Deciduous (0.495545): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc | yago
Resurrection (0.485434): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc
Forest (0.484008): dbpedia | freebase | opencyc